Former Manchester United midfielder Paul Ince has offered a measured assessment of Michael Carrick’s permanent appointment at Old Trafford, praising the tactical simplicity he restored to the squad while warning that the real test is yet to come.
Carrick took over on an interim basis in January following Ruben Amorim’s dismissal, quickly abandoning the unpopular 3-4-2-1 system in favour of a traditional 4-3-3.
After leading United to a stunning top-four finish, the 44-year-old was rewarded with a permanent contract until 2028.
Immediate impact
While former England star Ince finds it ironic that Carrick landed one of football’s biggest jobs so soon after being sacked by Middlesbrough, he acknowledges the immediate impact the former midfielder has made on dressing room morale.
However, with Champions League football returning to Old Trafford, Ince warns that United’s thin squad must be significantly reinforced if they are to genuinely challenge Manchester City and Arsenal for the Premier League title.
During an exclusive conversation with BestBettingSites, Ince said of Carrick’s appointment: “Listen, I don’t want to get deluded here, but if you look at the time since Sir Alex Ferguson left, we’ve had about seven or eight managers.
“And everyone has asked me the exact same question as soon as a new manager gets the post – whether it was Jose Mourinho or whoever – “Is the future looking bright for United?” You can only really say yes until they get sacked.
“To be fair, I said from day one when Ole Gunnar Solskjær took over that they should have gone and got Mauricio Pochettino. That was my thing: go and get Poch.
“Alright, they got Solskjær, he did well at the back end of that season, they gave him a long-term contract, and then it all went to pieces in the new season.
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Premier League news: Paul Ince backs new Man Utd signing Ederson after £35m transfer
Calmness to the team
“So when you ask me about Michael Carrick, I think he has brought some calmness to the team.
“To me, it looked like you had a team under Rúben Amorim playing a 3-5-2 system that none of the players actually wanted to play.
“Then Carrick comes in and plays the 4-3-3 that everybody wants to play, so you naturally expect an improvement.
“I think everyone got a bit giddy when they beat Arsenal and Manchester City, so it was like, “Yeah, yeah, give him the job permanently.
Massive bonus
“The fact that they got into the Champions League this year is a massive bonus.
“It is funny though, because he lost his job at Middlesbrough, and you think: you lose your job at Boro and then you get the job at one of the biggest clubs in the world?
“That doesn’t usually make sense. But he has gone in there, he has done ever so well, and the players seem to like him.
“The start of this season is going to be incredibly important.
“Last year they had no Champions League, just the Premier League calendar.
“Now they are going to have a lot of midweek games and all that travel, so it will be interesting to see how he handles that rotation.
“I like the way Carrick carries himself, I like the way he deals with the press, and hopefully they get off to a good start this season.
World Cup 2026 news: ‘Keep on going’, Thomas Tuchel tells England star Jude Bellingham
All about titles and trophies
“We want to see the future look bright because Manchester United is about winning titles and winning trophies; it’s not just about qualifying for the Champions League.
“There are four or five places now to get into the Champions League, so the standard has to be competing with the likes of City and Arsenal.
“Those teams will be stronger next year, and Liverpool will be stronger next year too.
“All United fans want is to make sure the team is up there truly competing for the title.
“If you’re not doing that, then there’s a problem.”
New signing praised
Ince, meanwhile, has backed new signing Ederson to be a massive hit at Old Trafford.
The Brazilian star has joined Carrick’s growing project following a €45 million (£35m) move from Serie A side Atalanta.
And Ince said: “I do like the boy Éderson they’ve just brought in from Atalanta.
“I think he’s a good midfield player. I still think they need to bring in another proper striker – someone who can guarantee you 25 to 30 goals a season.
“Defensively, they also need another centre-half and a right-back, so there is still a lot of work for them to do to improve for next season.”
READ NEXT: Premier League news: Enzo Maresca in dreamland after taking Man City job
Michael Davey